Skip to main content

Table 2 Concordance of interictal and ictal magnetic source imaging (MSI) on lobar and sublobar levels

From: Interictal and Ictal MEG in presurgical evaluation for epilepsy surgery

Author

Year

Concordant ictal/interictal

Total

Remarks

  

lobar

sublobar

lobar information

sublobar information

Sutherling [22]

1987

2

NsA

2

NA

 

Stefan [23]

1992

1

NA

1

1

 

Ishibashi [37]

1998

1

NA

1

NA

 

Kirchberger [38]

1998

2

2

2

2

 

Ko [39]

1998

2

2

2

2

 

Bowyer [40]

2000

1

1

1

1

 

Shiraish [41]

2001

4

NA

4

NA

 

Eliashev [24]

2002

4

NA

5

NA

 

Tilz [25]

2002

5

NA

6

NA

 

Oishi [42]

2002

1

1

1

1

 

Assaf [18]

2003

2

2

2

2

 

Tang [43]

2003

5

5

5

5

 

Yoshinaga [44]

2004

2

1

2

2

 

Tayah [45]

2006

2

1

3

3

 

Vitkainen [46]

2009

2

NA

2

NA

 

Xiang [47]

2010

4

3

4

4

HFO

Yagyu [28]

2010

3

3

3

3

Frequency

Kakisaka [48]

2011

1

NA

2

NA

 

Medvedovsky [20]

2012

7

6

12

12

 

Schmitt & Rampp [30]

2012

1

1

1

NA

 

Alkawadri [19]

2018

21

18

21

21

Frequency

Fujiwara [27]

2012

4

0

8

8

Frequency

Jeong [31]

2016

9

8

13

13

Frequency

Pellegrino [33]

2016

13

13

11

13

wMEM

Shirozu [34]

2017

12

10

12

12

GMFT

Velmurugan [49]

2018

12

NA

20

NA

HFO

Total

 

123

77

146

105

 
  

84%

73%

   

Not included

     

Reason

Badier [32]

2016

  

6

 

No interictal information

Koptelova [50]

2018

  

7

 

Extended activity

Ramajunam [21]

2017

19

9

32

 

Indirect information

  1. NA no information available, HFO high frequency oscillation, wMEM wavelet-based maximum entropy on the mean, GMFT gardient magnetic field topography